Condiments are some of the easiest things to forget about in the refrigerator. You buy a jar of horseradish for a holiday dinner, open a bottle of dressing for a salad, and months later, they’re still taking up space on the refrigerator door.
Because we tend to use condiments in small amounts, it’s easy to keep them well beyond their recommended storage time. And while a printed expiration or best-by date doesn’t necessarily mean something is unsafe to eat, certain condiments require more caution than others, especially after opening.
Here are nine condiments worth checking the next time you clean out your refrigerator.

Barbecue Sauce
It’s easy to forget about a partially used bottle of barbecue sauce once grilling season ends. Although many varieties keep for several months after opening, check the label before using a bottle left over from last summer.
Mayonnaise
If you can’t remember when you opened that jar of mayonnaise, it might be time to replace it. Commercial mayonnaise generally keeps for about two months after opening when properly refrigerated. Any signs of mold, discoloration, or an unusual smell are reasons to toss it.
Related: 12 Things Almost Everyone Keeps in Their Junk Drawer but Probably Shouldn’t
Ranch Dressing
That half-empty bottle of ranch dressing won’t stay good indefinitely. Creamy dressings, including ranch, blue cheese, and Caesar, can be more perishable than vinegar-based alternatives. Check the manufacturer’s storage recommendations and discard any dressing that develops mold, an unpleasant odor, or an unusual consistency.
Jarred Garlic in Oil
Garlic stored in oil deserves extra attention because improper storage can allow the bacteria responsible for botulism to grow. Follow the storage instructions on commercially prepared products, and refrigerate homemade garlic-in-oil mixtures for no more than four days or freeze them. Dangerous contamination isn’t always something you can see or smell.
Chili Oil
A bottle of commercially prepared chili oil may have a relatively long shelf life, but homemade versions containing fresh garlic or peppers are a different story. Fresh ingredients submerged in oil can create conditions that allow botulism toxin to develop. Follow safe preparation and storage guidelines, and discard homemade batches kept beyond their recommended storage period.
Fresh Salsa
Unlike shelf-stable salsa, fresh refrigerated salsa has a relatively short lifespan. It’s especially easy to forget about an opened container after taco night or a weekend gathering. Throw it away if it’s beyond its recommended storage period or shows signs of mold, unexpected bubbling, or a slimy texture.
Prepared Horseradish
Horseradish is one of those condiments many people buy for a specific meal and rarely use again. It gradually loses its signature sharpness after opening, even when refrigerated. Flavor loss is a quality issue, but mold or an unusual odor means the jar belongs in the trash.
Pesto
Between the fresh basil, cheese, garlic, nuts, and oil, pesto is more perishable than many other sauces. Use store-bought pesto within the recommended timeframe after opening, and refrigerate homemade pesto for only a few days. If you rarely finish an entire jar, consider freezing individual portions for future meals.
Ketchup
Ketchup has a relatively long shelf life thanks to its acidity, but an opened bottle isn’t meant to be kept indefinitely. Check the manufacturer’s storage recommendations, particularly if it’s been sitting in your refrigerator for a year or longer.
